Automation Isn’t the Challenge—Leadership Is

The Agency
2 days ago
3 min read

Silhouettes of people walking on a red and white background.

Hiring managers, the insurance industry is undergoing a major transformation. The impact of January 2025’s Los Angeles wildfires still lingers, the $37 billion fallout from 2024’s hurricane season remains a financial cautionary tale, and the ripple effect of newly imposed tariffs is driving repair costs up by 20% (Aon, 2025). At the same time, nearly 40% of insurers are fast-tracking claims automation using AI and small language models (SLMs), betting on efficiency gains and leaner operations (Deloitte, 2025).

Amid this shift, a deeper issue is emerging: leadership. Insurers face growing demand for leaders skilled in AI-driven claims processes, as automation reshapes roles and raises the bar for strategic oversight (Vertafore, 2025). In this high-pressure environment, the ability to harness automation while controlling claims costs is no longer a competitive edge—it’s a requirement.

Why Automation Demands a New Breed of Claims Leader

Claims automation—once relegated to back-office tasks—is now influencing front-line leadership. AI and SLMs are handling document reviews, triaging claims, and detecting fraud, but this only raises the bar for human oversight. Today’s directors must be capable of deploying these tools while guiding teams through volatile claims cycles and emerging cost risks. Progressive’s Flo chatbot and Allstate’s AI-driven claims workflows already report cost reductions nearing 25%. Without the right leadership, these tools risk becoming underutilized assets instead of performance drivers.

Three Key Pressures Forcing a Leadership Evolution:

Operational Strategy Beyond Savings: Automation’s true value lies in enabling leaders to strategically allocate resources, navigate large-scale events, and prioritize high-complexity cases. It's about resilience as much as efficiency.
Digital Competency as a Leadership Baseline: As AI adoption rises and senior talent retires, the leadership gap isn’t just about numbers—it’s about fluency. Directors must be equipped to align automation capabilities with claims performance.
Economic Strain from Tariffs: 2025 tariffs (10–25%) on car parts have already driven repair costs up by 20%. Forward-thinking leaders will need to lean on automation to maintain margins and competitiveness.

Despite the rapid adoption of automation, insurers face a bottleneck: too few leaders possess the strategic and technical literacy needed to fully leverage these systems. This is where The Agency delivers value—identifying, vetting, and placing claims leaders with the right combination of AI fluency, cost control experience, and vision for long-term success.

4 Strategies to Build Future-Ready Claims Leadership

To lead effectively in this next phase, insurers must proactively shape their talent strategy around four key priorities:

Hire for Digital Fluency, Not Just Experience
Today’s claims leaders must understand platforms like ClaimVantage and the capabilities of GenAI. Look for executives who’ve led automation rollouts and driven measurable gains. Prioritize digital aptitude alongside operational expertise.
Upskill from Within to Preserve Institutional Knowledge
While external hires are critical, internal teams shouldn’t be left behind. Offer structured upskilling in data analytics and AI tools (e.g., through Skillsoft or internal L&D programs) to turn current staff into strategic assets.
Recruit Leaders Who Can Mitigate Cost Pressures
The rise in repair costs requires more than budget-cutting. Seek leaders skilled in process optimization, vendor negotiations, and AI-based decision support to keep costs under control without sacrificing service quality.
Support Talent Retention Through Flexibility
Top-tier talent is increasingly drawn to employers offering adaptability. Hybrid schedules, outcome-focused management, and flexibility in roles are not perks—they’re expectations. Highlight these in your job offers to stay competitive.

Build the Team Others Will Be Competing For Tomorrow

Claims automation is changing more than processes—it’s redefining what leadership looks like. From climate volatility to tariff-driven cost spikes, the margin for error is shrinking. The most successful insurers will be those with leaders who combine deep insurance expertise with a strategic command of automation technologies.

At The Agency, we specialize in identifying and placing the tech-forward claims leaders who are already driving results at the highest level. We understand the intersection of technology, strategy, and leadership—and we’re here to help you build a future-ready team before the market forces your hand.

Sources: